In addition, it could prevent some tragic consequences of bullying. This is unlikely to stop bullying. A great reason would be, retaliation for something similarly done to them, the other person instigating it, as in they irritate or annoy excessively, and in the case of ignoring if they are of a feuding family or oppose one of your morals.
There is a recent study showing that bullies on average tend to have it much better socially than the victims they persecute. On Punishment for Bullying — and Punishment as Bullying By Alfie Kohn Bullying at school has attracted an enormous amount of attention, spurring academic studies and popular books, regulations and training sessions for educators.
I would first like to start out by saying any physical attack or physical threat should not be tolerated, as I believe that the act of hurting an individual, forcing an individual to do something, or threatening an individual is not bullying, it is worse than bullying.
Worse still, criminally charging the perpetrators may end neither the bullying nor the suffering of the victim. As a result, most schools are left to incorporate them only as far as their notoriously strapped budgets and resources allow.
If schools were to focus on effective early intervention for bullies instead of waiting to punish bullying behavior after the fact, it is likely they would see a decrease in bullying and suspensions and expulsions. These changes to anti-bullying laws are good first steps, but recognizing the problem is not sufficient.
A week of outcries: Indeed, the teasing, the emotional harm, the disenfranchisement and the dislike of the victim may increase, especially if the kids arrested are popular, or if their friends and other community members believe that the accusations or arrests were unjustified or a disproportionate response.
Moving on to punishments in place for bullies already. In general, the heavy hand of criminal law is a poor deterrent to most crimes.
There are alternative, more effective means of preventing and dealing with bullying. InNevada revised its anti-bullying law to Bullies need a harsher punishment for, among other things, hiring social workers to provide services to address the bullying problem and its effects.
They may not have the capability to learn the decency just yet on how to deal with so many other people their own age. A punishment is a response by someone with more power say, an adult to a prohibited action on the part of someone with less power in this case, a child.
Well, we are going to hurt you even more," we threaten. Perhaps the very notion of putting a bunch of immature kids into a small space by themselves for five days a week is a huge mistake.
Reports indicate that a female student was the victim of emotional, physical, and cyber-bullying -- all pointing toward another possibly tormented young life. Taking away recess, handing out zeroes, forcing children to stay after school, sending unpleasant reports home to parents, exiling students from the classroom or school — and threatening in advance to do these things to them if they fail to obey us — may not have been intended as bullying.
Maybe traditional discipline is a kind of bullying. Rather, punishment in general is likely a hidden contributor to bullying, both because of what it models and because of its effects on the students who are punished.
Do we look for solutions that can help both the victims and the bullies and will be transformative for everyone? Of the many options available to deal with bullying and bullies, the criminal law is the harshest, most punitive response we can use against anyone, particularly young people, who are still developing and often fighting their own emotional battles.
Moreover, such studies also suggest that students who bully may have behavioral or emotional problems that require intervention in order to address the root cause of bullying.
Messenger The spring legislative season is well underway, and, as has been the case for the last several years, a number of states are again considering and passing amendments to their anti-bullying laws. Indeed, the vast majority of these laws call for nothing more in response to bullying than punishment of the bully.
However, bullying continues to be a widespread and pernicious problem. Did educators and parents try other, more effective, more empowering means of resolving the problem? But the effects of punishment do matter, and where bullying is concerned, they suggest a painful irony: They require changes in our habits and an examination of how we, as adults, speak about colleagues and peers.
The intent may be to discourage the child from repeating the action, but the more common results of punishment are that the child 1 becomes angry and frustrated, 2 learns that you get your way in life by using your power over those who are weaker, and 3 becomes more focused on self-interest and less likely to consider how his actions affect others.
Bullying can have significant and sometimes tragic effects. When students are suspended or expelled from school, they typically sit home with nothing to do. Bullying can lead to decreased academic performanceincreased school dropout rates, increased depression and even suicide in some extreme cases.
InUCLA researchers explored the popularity of this retributive rationale on the part of teachers. The truth is these laws can both help and hurt students. Skip the other efforts and we are abdicating our responsibility as parents and as a community, and leaving everything to the heavy hand of the criminal law, which should only and always be used as a last resort.
In her suicide note, Hailee asked that her school be informed of the reasons she committed suicide so that the school would prevent bullying from harming other students in the future.
But it is equally likely that under pressure to respond forcefully to bullying, the police cast the net too wide and arrested too many people.
A person who has been bullied builds a better sense of self, as they are bullied they defy the bully by developing a strong sense of self worth and self respect.Jul 26, · Should cruel carers get harsher punishments?
Coleen Feels That Banning the Term 'Pregnant Woman' Is Taking Gender Neutral Too Far | Loose Women - Duration: Loose Womenviews. Simply punishing bullies does not work All 50 states and the District of Columbia now have anti-bullying laws.
However, bullying continues to be a. School Bullying and it's Consequences. teachers that are bullies, and peer bullying. Many of these bullied students don’t get the support they need after they’ve been attacked. Simply. School Bullies Need Harsher Punishments Bullies in schools need to receive harsher punishments than the slaps on the wrist they receive now.
Without a doubt, these bullies cause lasting psychological harm to their victims, and they need to. Harsher Punishment For School Bullies Those who witness bullying, but don't say anything about it, are more likely to have mental illness than someone who reports it.
Over two-thirds of students believe that schools respond poorly to bullying, with a high percentage of students believing that adult help is infrequent and ineffective.
Stricter punishment is not the solution, for precisely the reason you mention, but the matter does need to still be approached from a different direction because of the ramifications neglecting it has for the bullied (as well as the bully).Download